'Prima Facie' Review: Cynthia Erivo Can't Save a Heavy-Handed Legal Drama

By Dan Bremner - November 16, 2026
The 2026 legal drama from Susanna White, adapted from Suzie Miller’s stage play of the same name (Miller also wrote the screenplay). It follows Tessa Ensler, a working-class criminal defence barrister in London who is used to representing clients accused of sexual assault, until she is raped by a co-worker and suddenly has to experience the courtroom from the other side. I haven’t seen the critically acclaimed one-woman play that made Jodie Comer’s name in the role, but I’m always up for a solid courtroom drama, and the idea of watching a stage piece opened up for the big screen, especially one tackling these themes, should have been interesting. Unfortunately, Prima Facie, even with a strong central performance from Cynthia Erivo, the flat direction and dead-on-the-nose writing turn a well-intentioned drama into a fairly clear missed opportunity.
The filmmaking itself is stiff and oddly literal. White’s approach feels more televisual than cinematic, with little sense of rhythm or visual imagination. There are aggressively on-the-nose choices that actively cheapen the material: cutaways to thoroughbred horses the moment someone refers to elite colleagues as “thoroughbreds,” or repeated shots of broken glass during the assault sequence that land with all the subtlety of a brick. Instead of deepening the drama, these images just underline points the film has already made several times over. It's a look that belongs on the BBC, not a cinema screen.
A big part of the problem is the constant voiceover. The play’s continuous internal monologue has been split into regular dialogue plus a near-nonstop running commentary from Tessa. It quickly becomes clumsy and redundant. Rather than trusting Erivo’s face and body language, the film keeps explaining what she’s feeling in the most explicit terms possible. The voiceover actively undercuts her performance, turning moments that could have been powerful and ambiguous into something closer to an illustrated lecture. It quickly becomes exhausting and annoying.
The early scenes don’t help the cause. Large stretches of the first act feel oddly cheesy, tipping into awkward quasi-rom-com territory with dancing to pop music and luxury ice-cream beats that play like product placement. The dialogue between colleagues often lands as forced or inauthentic, so the world of the chambers never quite feels lived-in before the central trauma arrives and the film has to get serious. I understand it helps create a false sense of security before the inciting incident happens, but it is rough and tough to watch at times as you try not to cringe.
What’s more interesting, and more uncomfortable, is watching Tessa spend that entire first act defending men accused of rape while openly stating that it isn’t her place to decide whether they’re guilty or not. The film presents this professional detachment as simple fact, and she is proud of her victories that allow dangerous men to escape justice, then asks us to sit with the shift when the same system turns on her. It’s one of the sharper ideas in the script, even if the surrounding scenes don’t always give it the space it needs.
Once it does get serious, the tone becomes heavily message-driven. There’s a persistent sense that the film is more interested in delivering a clear systemic indictment and engineering a theatrical triumph for its heroine than in fully immersing you in the messy, contradictory experience of what she’s going through. The righteousness of the argument is never in doubt, but the drama around it often feels strained and obvious, as if the film is worried the audience might miss the point if it isn’t restated every few minutes.
One of the stranger omissions is how little time is spent on the sheer grinding weight of the wait for trial, which is a staggering 1,107 days. The film skips over or only lightly touches the emotional and psychological toll of those years, preferring to stay with the legal mechanics rather than sitting with the daily devastation of living with unresolved trauma for that long. It’s a missed opportunity that would have added real weight to an undercooked drama.
Even the climax, while powerfully delivered, feels more stagey than cinematic. The big courtroom monologue gives Erivo a chance to cut loose, but it plays like a rhetorical set-piece designed to give the character a clean emotional win rather than something that fully engages with the complicated, often unsatisfying realities survivors actually face. It works as theatre, as cinema it's clunky and incredibly forced.

The one element that consistently rises above the material is Cynthia Erivo herself. She gives a fierce, commanding central performance that carries moral authority and real emotional depth. She’s especially strong in the raw middle section that deals with the immediate aftermath and the ongoing effects of the assault, and she holds the later courtroom scenes together through sheer force of presence. Without her the film would be in much deeper trouble.
The supporting cast around Erivo never really get the chance to make much of an impression. Daniel Ings, Toheeb Jimoh, Sophia Nomvete and more, merely exist to feed her the next line or to represent a particular institutional attitude, and the film rarely allows them the room to become anything more than there. You keep waiting for someone else to complicate the picture or push back in a meaningful way, but the script keeps the focus so tightly on Tessa that everyone else ends up feeling like furniture.
The subject matter itself remains urgent and necessary. Consent, the failures of the justice system around sexual assault, the scrutiny survivors are put under, the ridiculous delays to trial, and the way class, race and gender all shape the process are all worth examining on screen. The film does at least make clear the system is not fit for purpose, so many people never report and how much courage it takes to go through the system at all. It’s just a shame the execution so often gets in the way of the points it’s trying to make.
Prima Facie is a well-intentioned but flatly directed and overly explicit legal drama that leans too hard on voiceover, on-the-nose imagery and a preachy tone, undercutting its own potential at almost every turn. Cynthia Erivo’s performance and the continuing relevance of the subject matter provide the only real reasons to engage, but they aren’t enough to overcome the stiff filmmaking, clumsy execution and lack of subtlety. A missed opportunity that never becomes the sharp, urgent courtroom drama it could have been.
'Prima Facie' is out now in cinemas following its release on November 13, 2026.

Want more film reviews? Dive into more reviews, rankings, and film conversations, explore Film Focus Online now!

Dan Bremner
Writer
Dan is a writer from Guildford with a love for all things genre, schlocky, and thoroughly '80s, and a part-time philanthropist.
Want your film or TV show reviewed by Dan? Contact us.



